Conundrum Cafe was established in 2005. It is located in the Village of Elberta, Michigan at the corner of M-22 and historic M-168 in a general mercantile building built in 1880. The village once know as South Frankfort has a rich history since the late 1800s: lumber and iron town, the Ann Arbor Railroad and Car Ferries, along with commercial and sport fishing .
The Bestie Valley Trail which follows the original Ann Arbor Railway and the scenic Betsie River are both just a step away from Conundrum Cafe’s front door. Beautiful Elberta Beach on Lake Michigan is a short ride from the Cafe. There is so much to see and do in Benzie County- the smallest county in Michigan.